Science Lesson: Keystone Oysters of NY Harbor
Lesson Plan
2 hours 25 minutesGrades9, 10, 11, 12Biology
This resource has been reviewed by SubjectToClimate's climate scientists and verified for scientific accuracy and up-to-date information. Learn about our review process →
Written by Sol Giesso
About this lesson
Students investigate how oysters function as a keystone species in New York Harbor, rotating through stations on filtration, habitat, storm protection, and reef building under ocean acidification. Students then act as restoration ecologists, using monitoring data from three sites to recommend where the city should focus restoration efforts.
Inquire: Students compare their neighborhood’s historical and present-day landscapes and learn about the oyster reef ecosystem the harbor once supported.
Investigate: Students circulate among four stations to learn about oysters’ roles as filters, habitats, barriers, and builders in New York Harbor.
Inspire: Students evaluate data from three oyster restoration sites, diagnose why new oysters are failing to survive, weigh ecological and community trade-offs, and recommend one site for next season’s restoration effort.
Preview the lesson plan
Better on a bigger screen? Open it in its own tab.View Resource
Everything you need to teach it
- Teacher SlideshowOpen
- Student DocumentOpen
- Teacher Answer KeyOpen
- Species CardsOpen
- Station Name SignsOpen
Teaching tips
Suggestions
- This lesson is designed to take place over two days. On the first day, students engage in the Inquire and Investigate sections (75 minutes). On the second day, students apply what they learned by taking on the role of restoration ecologists in the Inspire section (70 minutes).
- This lesson can be used in ecology units in Biology, Environmental Science, and Earth Science courses, including relevant AP courses.
- The Inspire section, or just the final recommendation, may be assigned as homework or be finished as homework.
- Teachers may choose to skip Station 3 (Barriers) if time is limited and instead introduce the concept of oyster reefs as barriers while presenting the extra information during the Inspire section.
- Alternatively, teachers may choose to adapt the lesson from stations to a jigsaw. If you do this, review the answers to the packet as a class before moving on to the Inspire section.
- Use the final activity as an assessment or exit ticket.
- This lesson is built around New York State Standards but is easily adaptable to Common Core-aligned classrooms. All primary standards map exactly to NGSS.
Prerequisites
- Set up the four stations in your classroom ahead of class time. You will need:
- General
- Printed copies of the Student Document for every student
- Printed station name signs
- Station 1: Oysters as Filters
- 4-5 printed copies of this article about how oysters filter water
- A computer or tablet set up to watch this video of oysters filtering (students can also use their own devices)
- (Recommended but not required) Sample of water in a clear container from the New York Harbor (can also be an image, such as the one on this website)
- Station 2: Oysters as Habitats
- 15-20 oyster shells for students to observe and build with (can be gathered from a local restaurant and cleaned with bleach or ordered online)
- 2 medium containers, one for storing shells and one for building the reef
- 1-2 printed and cut copies of the species cards
- Station 3: Oysters as Barriers
- A computer or tablet set up to watch this video about different barriers (students can also use their own devices)
- 1-2 printed copies of the map of projected NYC floodplains (toggle on “Future Projections” to 2050s before printing)
- 1-2 printed copies of the map of areas that flooded during Hurricane Sandy
- Station 4: Oysters as Builders
- 4-5 printed copies of this article about how dissolved carbon dioxide interferes with shell formation
- General
- Post the rotation schedule on the board so transitions between stations take under a minute. Add student names to the rotation slide on the Teacher Slideshow.
- Assign one “materials monitor” per group to reset their station before the group rotates, so it is ready for the next group. You can do this by bolding or highlighting a student name in the slideshow group assignment.
- Students should have a basic understanding of food webs, pH, reading tables, and creating bar graphs.
Differentiation
- In a Biology course, this lesson can be used to cover keystone species and human impact on ecosystems. The Inspire section’s data analysis serves as practice for Regents exams.
- If you only have time for two stations, prioritize Station 2 (Habitats) and Station 4 (Builders), which are most directly tied to interdependence and reproductive/life cycle standards. You can assign the Station 1 (Filters) article and filtration-rate calculation as homework.
- If doing all four stations, highlight the Station 2 species-classification activity and the Station 4 life cycle diagram.
- For an AP Biology course, shift extra time toward the Inspire section’s quadrat sampling and population trend analysis, which align closely with the Ecology unit, specifically the Population Ecology, Community Ecology, and Disruptions in Ecosystems topics.
- In an Environmental Science course, this lesson can be used to reinforce themes of ecosystem services, biogeochemical cycles, and human impact.
- If you only have time for two stations, prioritize Station 1 (Filters) and Station 4 (Builders), which cover filtration as an ecosystem service and the mechanics of ocean acidification.
- If doing all four stations, highlight the Station 1 filtration-rate calculation and the Station 4 acidification mechanism.
- For an AP Environmental Science course, engage with all four stations and the full Inspire tradeoff analysis, as all activities reinforce a variety of core topics. Station articles may be replaced with more complex scientific articles and assigned as pre-reading homework, if desired. In addition, students can be asked to sort oysters’ ecosystem services by type (provisioning, regulating, cultural, supporting).
- In an Earth Science course, this lesson can be used to reinforce understanding of climate change and human impacts on Earth systems.
- If you only have time for two stations, prioritize Station 3 (Barriers) and Station 4 (Builders), which cover sea level rise/Hurricane Sandy comparisons and ocean acidification. The other two stations can be assigned as reading homework.
- If doing all four stations, highlight the Station 3 floodplain map comparison and the Station 4 acidification article.
- As an extension, sign up for one of the Billion Oyster Project’s professional development opportunities and kickstart your classroom’s own oyster research tank.
- To support English language learners, provide sentence stems or frames to scaffold the recommendation paragraph. You may also choose to pre-teach vocabulary words.
- For struggling students, provide a worked example of one quadrat calculation (average adults/spat) before students tackle the three-site data set on their own.
- Have more advanced students research and calculate the actual dollar cost of the ecosystem services lost at whichever site they do not recommend in the Inspire section.
Want this to fit your class?
Add your location for local examples, questions, and action ideas.
About the teacher writer
Sol Giesso
Content Writer
Sol Giesso, Ed.M., is SubjectToClimate's Content Writer and a middle school math teacher in Boston. She holds an M.S. in Community Climate Adaptation from Worcester Polytechnic Institute and an Ed.M. in Teaching and Teacher Leadership from the Harvard Graduate School of Education, and previously worked at the Smithsonian Environmental Research Center leading hands-on outdoor education field trips for K–12 students. Fun fact: she loves to draw, scuba dive, and turn any recipe into a vegetarian one.

